50 американских морских пехотинцев против 50 русских элитных бойцов

Кто победит в сражении 50 американских морских пехотинцев против 50 русских элитных бойцов?

Такой вопрос нашел на западном ресурсе:

https://www.quora.com/Who-woul...

Видимо автор насмотрелся голливудщины.

Джо Франсис, офицер американской морской пехоты в отставке с 26 летним стажем дал ответ.

Я люблю мою страну и я горжусь моей службой и скажу честно без обиняков. Вам это наверное не понравится.
В бою между Русской элитой и простыми пехотинцами, все пехотинцы быдут быстро убиты, в то время как русский спецназ обойдется минимальными потерями.

Далее идет речь о том, что спецназ -- это высшая лига, а обычные морпехи -- немного получше простых солдат.

В последнем абзаце Джо называер русских солдат фантастическими. Высоко оценивает их патриотизм и желание защищать Родину.

Оригинальный вопрос и ответ скопированы ниже:

Who would win between 50 US Marines and 50 of Russia’s top military personnel in a firefight?

Joe Francis

Joe Francis, worked at U.S. Marine Corps

Updated Nov 22, 2017 · Upvoted by David Solorzano, former 0311 Rifleman (SF and MEUSOC) at U.S. Marine Corps and Zachary Mays, former Marine at U.S. Marine Corps (2000-2008)

I am a retired Army officer with 26 years of experience. I speak only for myself, but I was also a Marine Sergeant.

I love my country and I am proud of my service but I will give you a brutally honest answer that you may not like if you are a US Marine.

In a firefight between the Russian military elite and average US Marines, all of the Marines would be killed very quickly and most of the Russian Spetznaz would still be standing.

To help qualify the answer, you asked if Russia’s “top” military personnel were to engage with Marines. The average US Marine is probably better trained and equipped than the “average” Russian soldier, but against Russian Spetznaz? It would be like pitting a high school football team against an NFL team - it would “obviously” be a lopsided conflict with a 100% chance of Spetznaz success.

Do not underestimate enemy soldiers who are not from your country. Rest assured that to be in the military elite of any modern country you must be very physically fit, you will have had many years of training, you will be a man that will fight rather than cower, and you will be a man that is not afraid to die for his country.

The truth is that Russian soldiers are fantastic and I mean that in the best way because it is true. Do not underestimate the amount of suffering the Russian people have been through in the 20th century. Do not underestimate their love for their country and their willingness to do whatever is necessary to defend it.